Reposted from GraspUseful resource
By Robert Bradley Jr. — October 13, 2021
“Goodbye and good riddance to the most costly, and probably the most ineffective clear coal facility ever constructed.” (Angus Harvey, beneath)
The short repair of coal gasification and CO2 storage is all however useless. Initiatives will proceed, and the subsidies will movement if Biden will get his method. However it’s greenwashing and greenwasting.
The shiny star to be, Plant Ratcliffe, higher often called the Kemper Venture, a $6.7 billion built-in gasification energy plant, was an experimental boondoggle from the beginning (mid-2010). The dream actually ended years in the past, with The Guardian reporting in March 2018:
“This was the flagship mission that was going to cleared the path for an entire new technology of coal energy vegetation,” mentioned Richard Heinberg, senior fellow on the Submit Carbon Institute. “If the preliminary mission doesn’t work then who’s going to spend money on any extra prefer it?”
Firm officers have blamed the failure on elements starting from competitors from tumbling pure gasoline costs to dangerous climate, dangerous timing and plain previous dangerous luck.
BOOM! Mississippi Energy’s Kemper Venture (Southern Firm) was blown up by a “managed implosion.” Amid the ruins is the know-how of changing the state’s plentiful lignite into artificial gasoline (syngas) to feed a 582-megawatt energy plant. Politics outlined the mission, with Mississippi Governor Haley Barbour presiding.
“If it had turn out to be operational with coal,” Wiki famous, “the Kemper Venture would have been a first-of-its-kind electrical energy plant to make use of gasification and carbon seize applied sciences at this scale.”
The Left Reacts
Political economist Angus Harvey described the futile dream that solely the US Division of Power et al. may have dreamed up:
That is the fantastic footage of the Kemper coal plant in Mississippi – one of many fossil gas trade’s greatest ever scams – being destroyed yesterday (to some pretty backing music).
A decade in the past, this supposed technological marvel was being marketed because the coal trade’s moonshot, a $7.5 billion mission to supply vitality from ‘clear coal.’ It by no means labored, however did handle to burn an enormous quantity of carbon and taxpayer cash within the course of. The ratepayers of one of many poorest states in America coughed up $2.8 billion for this fuckup, after which an additional $1 billion in 2012 after the state’s governor used his energy to drive Mississippi Energy to pay for it in bonds owned by prospects.
Simply to place this into context: the funds for the primary company in the USA that handles substance abuse and psychological well being, the Substance Abuse and Psychological Well being Providers Administration (SAMHSA), is round $4.1 billion. As an alternative of spending this cash on a coal plant that by no means labored, that company’s funding may have been doubled for a yr. Decisions huh?
Final summer season the plant’s proprietor introduced it was abandoning building after years of blown-out budgets and missed building deadlines.
Goodbye and good riddance to the most costly, and probably the most ineffective clear coal facility ever constructed.
Susan Krumdieck, a self-described “creator and thought chief in Power Transition Engineering,” added:
What a multitude. However a minimum of we are able to use the proof, and by no means take into account doing this “clear coal” nonsense once more.
In the present day some economists received the Nobel Prize for utilizing “pure experiments” – which apparently means taking a look at what occurs in the actual world and utilizing actual information. Sensible.
This can be a pure experiment in “The Emperor’s New Garments”. When pressures are constructing, the power to undertake nonsense as a “resolution” to the issue can tackle gargantuan scale.
To which the critic can say: That is what you get whenever you attempt to invert actuality with dilute, intermittent energies substituting for dense, dependable ones–for wind/photo voltaic substituting for pure gasoline/coal.
To finish politics, Ms. Krumdieck, rethink the futile, wasteful campaign towards carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. Finish the struggle towards reasonably priced, dependable, utilitarian mineral energies.
Supply & Picture rights : https://wattsupwiththat.com/2021/10/14/kemper-coal-gasification-storage-plant-imploded-obamas-climate-centerpiece-bites-the-dust/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=kemper-coal-gasification-storage-plant-imploded-obamas-climate-centerpiece-bites-the-dust
Below Part 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “truthful use” for functions corresponding to criticism, remark, information reporting, instructing, scholarship, and analysis. Honest use is a use permitted by copyright statute which may in any other case be infringing.”